Electric scooter vs Petrol scooter – Which is best

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

long story short: Time for electric vs petrol scooter cost comparison in India in terms of short-term & long-term running cost, maintenance, pros, cons future of both and much more in detail with numbers.

The scooter market in India is buzzing like never before, emerging as one of the fastest-growing sectors in the automotive landscape. As the demand for personal mobility solutions surges, scooters have quickly become the go-to choice for commuters nationwide. We navigate a lively battle between two leading contenders: petrol and electric scooters.

Each option, petrol and electric scooters presents unique advantages and challenges, creating a compelling comparison for consumers. This detailed analysis will delve into the performance, running costs, environmental impacts, and convenience, providing a comprehensive understanding to aid in your decision-making process.

We’ll start by examining the running costs of petrol and electric scooters in India over 5, 3, and 1-year periods, followed by a detailed comparison and conclusion.

Comparison of running cost of Electric scooter vs petrol scooter in India

Let’s compare two popular scooters that represent the best of both worlds: the Honda Activa 6G, a reliable petrol scooter, and the Ather 450X, a cutting-edge electric scooter. We’ll explore their running costs over 5, 3, and 1-year periods, giving you a clear picture of what to expect.

1. Ex-Showroom Price, GST & Subsidy

Please note that the above-mentioned are Delhi’s ex-showroom prices as of January 2025.

1. The Ather 450X has a higher ex-showroom price than the Honda Activa 6G.
2. The price difference is mainly due to the cost of the electric motor and battery technology.
3. Petrol scooters with engines of 150cc or less are taxed at 18% GST.
4. Petrol scooters with engines above 150cc are taxed at 28% GST.
5. The ex-showroom price includes GST, covering manufacturing costs and the dealer’s profit margin.
6. There are no subsidies for petrol two-wheelers in India.
7. Electric scooters have a 5% GST rate, irrespective of battery capacity.
8. The EMPS 2024 Subsidy reduces the on-road price of the Ather 450X by Rs 10,000.
9. Subsidy for electric two-wheelers: Rs 5,000 per kWh of battery capacity capped at 15% of the vehicle’s factory price.
10. Reduced from the previous FAME II scheme that offered Rs 10,000 per kWh.

2. Registration Fees

Please note registration fees are similar for both petrol and electric scooters and might change among states across India.

3. Road Tax

1. Honda Activa 6G: Petrol scooters generally attract a higher road tax of 6% of the ex-showroom price.
2. Ather 450X: Electric vehicles benefit from a lower road tax rate of about 2% of the ex-showroom price. In some states, the road tax is fully exempted for electric scooters in India.

Please note that road tax varies from state to state for electric and petrol scooters in India. Refer to the Mparivahan website or the official dealer for exact details.

4. Insurance

1. Honda Activa 6G: Comprehensive cover (Own Damage + Third Party) for 1 year and third party only for the remaining 4 years; the amount is ₹6,500.
2. Ather 450X: Comprehensive cover (Own Damage + Third Party) for 1 year and third party only for the remaining 4 years; the amount is ₹6,500.

Please note that comprehensive insurance varies from the company and premium value changes annually for electric and petrol scooters in India. Refer to the respective insurance company for exact details.

5. On-Road Price

On-road price includes ex-showroom price plus additional costs required to legally drive the scooter, including road tax, registration fees and 5-year insurance, etc.

6. Battery Replacement

1. Honda Activa 6G: Normally has a 3-year warranty for the battery, and it is advisable to replace it after this timeframe.
2. Ather 450X: Normally, the battery has a 5-year warranty and is advisable to be replaced after this timeframe.

Please note that battery cost and replacement charges vary from the company for electric and petrol scooters in India. Please get in touch with respective battery manufacturers for exact prices and replacement costs.

7. Tyre Replacement

1. Honda Activa 6G: The total tyre replacement cost is around ₹3,000 for both tyres.
2. Ather 450X: The total tyre replacement cost is around ₹3,500 for both tyres.

The rear tyre for the electric scooter is slightly expensive as more battery weight is applied on the rear side and tyre, resulting in more wear.

8. Maintenance Costs

1. Honda Activa 6G: Petrol scooters require frequent maintenance, like oil changes, air filter cleaning, and spark plug checks.
2. Ather 450X: Electric scooters have fewer moving parts and require less maintenance, mainly limited to software updates and checks.

9. Fuel & Electricity Cost

Honda Activa 6G

1. Based on 47 km/l mileage and an annual distance of 10,000 km, the fuel cost comes to approximately ₹2.12 per km.
2. Calculation: 10,000 km / 47 km per litre = 212 litres of fuel needed for 1 year for travelling 10,000 km.
3. Multiply 212 litres x Rs 100 per litre = Rs 21,200.
4. Divide the total fuel cost by total kilometres driven: 21200 / 10000 = Rs 2.12 per km.

Ather 450X

1. Based on 2.9 kWh per 100 km, the electricity cost comes to approximately ₹0.23 per km.
2. Calculation: 10,000 km / 100 km range = 100 kWh needed for 1 year for travelling 10,000 km.
3. Multiply 100 kWh x 2.9 kWh battery capacity x Rs 8 per kWh = Rs 2,320.
4. Divide the total electric cost by the total kilometres driven: 2320 / 10000 = Rs 0.23 per km.

10. Electric scooter vs petrol scooter in India – 5-Year Total Running Cost Summary (10,000kms per year)

The table below represents a detailed 5-year electric vs petrol scooter cost comparison in India. Also, note that these values are approximate and never exact.

Please note that whether 3 years or 1 year, the customer must take 5 years of mandatory insurance, which includes a comprehensive plan for the first year and the rest of the year’s third-party insurance plan.

11. Electric scooter vs petrol scooter in India – 3-Year Total Running Cost Summary (10,000kms per year)

The table below represents a detailed 3-year electric vs. petrol scooter cost comparison in India. Also, note that these values are approximate and never exact.

Please note that whether 3 years or 1 year, the customer must take 5 years of mandatory insurance, which includes a comprehensive plan for the first year and the rest of the year’s third-party insurance plan.

12. Electric scooter vs petrol scooter in India – 1-Year Total Running Cost Summary (10,000kms per year)

The table below represents a detailed 1-year electric vs petrol scooter cost comparison in India. Also, note that these values are approximate and never exact.

Please note that whether 3 years or 1 year, the customer must take 5 years of mandatory insurance, which includes a comprehensive plan for the first year and the rest of the year’s third-party insurance plan.

Electric scooter vs petrol scooter in India – Which is better for you regarding running cost?

1. Initial Costs: The Honda Activa 6G stands out as a more affordable option in terms of the ex-showroom price and the on-road cost, providing potential buyers with a sense of financial security.
2. Long-Term Costs: Despite the higher initial cost, the Ather 450X is a prudent choice with a significantly lower long-term running cost, thanks to the cheaper fuel/electricity costs, lower maintenance, and the EMPS subsidy.
3. Environmental Impact: The Ather 450X offers a greener alternative with fewer emissions. It aligns with the values of environmentally conscious consumers, making it a responsible choice.

While petrol scooters like the Honda Activa 6G offer a lower upfront cost, electric scooters like the Ather 450X are more cost-efficient in the long run and align with the country’s push towards a sustainable future.

Comparison of Electric scooter vs petrol scooter in India

Now, let’s look into a common comparison of electric and petrol scooters in India, with details of the pros and cons.

1. Performance, Mileage & Range

Petrol Scooters

1. Speed & Power: Petrol scooters typically offer more power with an average 4-6 bhp range, making them suitable for higher speeds and longer trips, especially on highways. The 100cc to 150cc engines provide good acceleration and performance.
2. Mileage: Petrol scooters generally have a fuel tank capacity of 5-7 litres, which gives them a range of approximately 200-300 km on a full tank, depending on the model and riding conditions.

Electric Scooters

1. Speed & Power: Electric scooters typically offer 2-5 bhp, depending on the motor. While their power is lower than that of petrol scooters, they provide instant torque, which results in smoother and quicker acceleration in city traffic. High-performance electric scooters like the Ather 450X or Ola S1 Pro can reach top speeds of around 100-115 km/h.
2. Range: The range of electric scooters has significantly improved, with many models offering 80-150 km per charge. With fast-charging technology, most electric scooters now have a charging time of 4-6 hours, although fast-charging options can bring this down to an hour or less.

2. Cost of Ownership

Petrol Scooters

1. Initial Price: Petrol scooters will be available at various prices, from budget models starting at ₹50,000 to premium models crossing ₹1 lakh.
2. Fuel Costs: Fuel is the most significant ongoing expense for petrol scooters. With fluctuating petrol prices in India, fuel costs vary, but an average scooter consumes 2-3 litres per 100 km.
3. Maintenance: Petrol scooters require regular maintenance, such as oil changes, chain adjustments, brake servicing, and air filter replacements. Depending on the model, annual maintenance costs can range from ₹1,500 to ₹5,000.

Electric Scooters

1. Initial Price: Electric scooters tend to be more expensive upfront. Prices for popular models like the Ather 450X, Ola S1 Pro, or Bajaj Chetak range from ₹90,000 to ₹1.5 lakh. However, government incentives and subsidies may lower some buyers’ prices.
2. Charging Costs: The cost of electricity is significantly lower than that of petrol. For example, charging an electric scooter may cost around ₹15-₹25 for a full charge, which gives a range of 80-150 km, depending on the model.
3. Maintenance: Electric scooters require minimal maintenance since they have fewer moving parts than petrol. There are no oil changes, and brake pads last longer. Maintenance costs are typically lower, averaging ₹500 to ₹2,000 per year.

3. Environmental Impact

Petrol Scooters

1. Petrol scooters contribute significantly to air pollution and carbon emissions. With rising concerns about climate change and pollution in India, the environmental footprint of petrol-powered vehicles has become a significant drawback.
2. The fuel combustion in petrol scooters releases harmful gases, including CO2, NOx, and particulate matter, which degrade air quality and contribute to global warming.

Electric Scooters

1. Eco-Friendly: Electric scooters produce zero tailpipe emissions, making them an environmentally friendly alternative to petrol scooters. They are powered by lithium-ion batteries, and although their manufacturing process does have some environmental impact, the overall carbon footprint is much lower than that of petrol vehicles.
2. Battery Disposal: One concern with electric scooters is the disposal of lithium-ion batteries. However, recycling programs and improved battery technology are continuously evolving to address this issue.

4. Convenience and Charging Infrastructure

Petrol Scooters

1. Refuelling: Petrol scooters enjoy the convenience of an extensive refuelling network across India, with fuel stations available in even the remotest of locations. Refuelling takes just a few minutes, which is one of the key reasons many consumers prefer petrol scooters.
2. Maintenance and Repairs: Petrol scooters have an extensive service network, with technicians and spare parts available efficiently, ensuring quick repairs and servicing.

Electric Scooters

1. Charging Infrastructure: While the availability of charging stations is improving, electric scooters still face challenges due to the lack of widespread charging infrastructure, especially in smaller cities and rural areas. However, major cities like Delhi, Mumbai, and Bengaluru have seen rapid growth in charging stations, and some electric scooter brands are working on expanding this network.
2. Home Charging: One of the main benefits of electric scooters is the ability to charge them at home. With a standard wall charger, you can recharge your scooter overnight, making it incredibly convenient for daily use.
3. Range Anxiety: Despite improvements in range, some users may still experience range anxiety, especially on long trips. However, fast-charging solutions are being developed to reduce this issue.

5. Government Support and Incentives

Petrol Scooters

1. Petrol scooters are not directly incentivized by the government, though the government does regulate emissions and fuel efficiency standards. Petrol vehicles are subject to higher taxes and fees. With the government’s push for electric mobility, they will likely face additional regulatory hurdles.

Electric Scooters

1. The Indian government offers various incentives for electric vehicles (EVs) under the Faster Adoption and Manufacturing of Hybrid and Electric Vehicles (FAME) scheme, which includes subsidies and tax benefits for electric scooter buyers.
2. States like Delhi, Maharashtra, and Karnataka offer additional subsidies on EVs, which will make electric scooters a more attractive option for consumers in 2025.

6. Market Trends and Future Outlook

Petrol Scooters

1. Petrol scooters maintain the largest market share in India. Still, their dominance is declining as awareness of fossil fuel impacts grows and electric mobility expands. They will remain popular in rural areas and among long-distance commuters needing higher range and quicker refuelling options.

Electric Scooters

1. Electric scooters will experience rapid growth in 2025 and beyond due to rising demand for eco-friendly transportation and government incentives. Advancements in battery technology, affordable pricing, and better charging infrastructure will help them dominate India’s market in the next 5-10 years.

Electric scooter vs petrol scooter in India – Which One is Better for You?

Choosing between a petrol or electric scooter in India is all about finding the perfect fit for your lifestyle, budget, and commuting needs.

Opt for a Petrol Scooter if:

1. You often hit the open road for long-distance adventures.
2. You can easily access refuelling stations and prefer a hassle-free top-up.
3. You’re looking for a wallet-friendly initial investment.

Choose an Electric Scooter if:

1. You care about the environment and want to reduce your carbon footprint.
2. Your daily commute revolves around city traffic, where an electric scooter shines.
3. You want to take advantage of government subsidies and incentives that make going electric even more appealing.

Electric scooters excel at short daily rides and come with significantly lower operational costs, not to mention their reduced environmental impact.

Ultimately, it’s a personal choice that should align with your commuting habits, values, and budget. And with the exciting advancements in electric mobility, it’s clear that the future of scooters in India is steering towards electric options. Get ready to ride the wave of change!

Other related articles from Bikeleague India

1. Best budget friendly scooters in India
2. Ather 450 X
3. Honda Activa
4. Honda Activa 125
5. KTM

Conclusion

Thank you for exploring the detailed comparison, running cost, and pros and cons of electric and petrol scooters in India. Don’t hesitate to ask questions or get more insights on India’s electric scooter vs petrol scooter cost comparison! You can email us at bikeleague2017@gmail.com or simply comment below – we’re always eager to assist you!. And remember, to stay in the loop and join our community, follow Bikeleague India on our social media platforms. Let’s ride safely together!